Finally, the servant who had received the one talent came and said, ‘Master, I knew that you are a hard man, reaping where you have not sown and gathering where you have not scattered seed. So I was afraid and went out and hid your talent in the ground. See, you have what belongs to you.’

‘You wicked, lazy servant!’ replied his master. ‘You knew that I reap where I have not sown and gather where I have not scattered seed. Then you should have deposited my money with the bankers, and on my return I would have received it back with interest.

Therefore take the talent from him and give it to the one who has ten talents. For everyone who has will be given more, and he will have an abundance. But the one who does not have, even what he thinks he has will be taken away from him. And throw that worthless servant into the outer darkness, where there will be weeping and gnashing of teeth.’

Matthew 25:24-30, MSB

Perhaps nowhere else in the Lord's parables is the metaphorical conceit of his story so distracting from its spiritual meaning than this one. We are so accustomed to obsession over money that its mention casts a spell over us, and we begin debating the details of economics which are unrelated from what I take to be the mind of the Lord in telling this story.

It is not that the choice of metaphor is not important, or that the details of its unfolding are not vital to understanding. Just the opposite: our preconceptions about money and labor cloud our reading and cause us to miss the finer points of the Lord's story.

Let us begin with one financial detail which a great many commentators, even translators, have missed: the two good and faithful servants are not said to have arrived at their increase by usury; that is, by speculative and exploitative lending. The best translations declare that these two put the money "to work." It is merely the mention of lending by the master later in the passage which leads to this confusion and obscures the importance of the inclusion of "interest" in the morality of the story. To this I will return later.

There is one more misapprehension by some commentators, relating to the ethical standing of the master. They take the witness of the third servant as reliable; that he is harsh and unjust, "harvesting what he did not sow." That any reader could interpret the master as the character of God in this story and also take this description at face value is a tragedy. The stark and unfavorable characterization ought to place our attention on alert -- upon the truth or falsity of this statement by the third servant will the rest of the wisdom of the parable turn. Giving primacy to the justice of God in all things, the faithful interpreter therefore arrives at one of two destinations: either the servant is wrong, or the master is not God at all. Both are worthy of consideration. But the other option -- that this parable declares the injustice of God -- is not worth further mention.

With these two details emphasized, we return to the parable in full, and let us begin by putting money and skills out of mind completely. The parable, as I read it, is about the life and growth of the spirit.

In this life, we are each "dealt a hand," from which we must play for the remainder of the game. One of the dangers of the parable is the simplification of this state of affairs into simple numerical values. In reality, what spiritual gifts we are given by God are not so easily comparable on a linear scale. One is given a happy disposition and a spirit of encouragement, another is given a great sensitivity to suffering and from it a lifelong twinge of melancholy. To each is appropriate a certain kind of service and a role in the community of God's family, and from the gifts of each arise a particular vocation. Paul expands on this quite effectively in 1 Corinthians 12:4-6 and elsewhere. It is no particular scandal that our gifts are diverse, both in character and proportion.

What may be scandalous is to imagine that God would stack the deck in this way, and then proceed to show favor to those to whom God had already granted particular privilege from the outset. Thankfully, this is not so. In fact, it is my belief that the parable will show precisely the opposite: God is not at all interested in that which we merely inherit, but entirely invested in what we work to bring forth from it. And, to this end, God is entirely just and fair to each; the condition of our endowment is always taken into account in the consideration of our increase. Both faithful servants worked to double their allotment, and both were congratulated with the same warmth. We must not be too quick to read approbation in the mere fact of one having 10 and another 6 when the master seem to take special notice of the difference in these sums. It is after the pattern of the world to consider the one with the greater sum as a victor. In the logic of the Kingdom, it is of the one to whom much has been given, that much will be required. Let no one look flippantly with envy upon the spiritual gifts granted to the greatest of prophets and saints, for among these not many were able to produce an increase commensurate with their gifts who did not also suffer and die for doing so. Happy are we who are given less and whose vocation, rather than turn the moral course of history as martyrs, is only to serve our families and communities. Let us then take comfort that a small and peaceful life of love may too be good and faithful to God.

Very well then, we are each granted some measure of spiritual gifts in our disposition, and God is pleased when we put these gifts to work in order to increase the abundance of the life of the Spirit in our lives and the entire world. Neither initial privilege nor final sum is the condition of this approval, but only our progress toward a perfection against which either 6, 10, or a thousand would be as a spark against the sun.

Now, what can be done with the fate of the final servant?

To resolve a sense of justice out of the calamity which befalls him -- one who by his own admission, in timidity and deference, merely secured what he was given -- we must turn aside from this parable from a moment to inquire as to the kind of person whom Jesus was intending to depict. We may begin to infer the archetype from the very next passage, which we know as the Parable of the Sheep and Goats.

It is interesting to me that these two parables stand next to one another in Matthew's Gospel. Matthew's recollection of Jesus' parable of the Talents is, despite its difficulty, far more palatable than Luke's troubling rendition of the same1. Matthew is also the only Gospel to record the Sheep and the Goats, one of the most revered of Jesus' recorded teachings on divine justice.

I believe that whenever we encounter symbols of wrath in Jesus' stories, we must resist the notion held by many Christians that such are representative of the 'sinner;' that being the non-believer, the outcast, the transgressive, the 'unclean.' One of the great gifts of the Parable of the Sheep and Goats is its assistance in correcting this mistake. For the outcast, the shunned, the 'worldly,' are everywhere finding ways to care for one another in solidarity and affirm the dignity of those the Church deems lesser-than. It is the proud and pious who step around the 'unclean' and desperate, pushing them to the outskirts and shoving them into prisons in an effort to hide (unconsciously or otherwise) the glaring incoherence of a belief in a God who blesses the righteous with comfort by divine election, and does not and shall never need their work of charity to feed one hungry child.

The cruelties of poverty, sickness, and even criminality are seen by such proud religious people as tacit signs of the insufficiency of God's grace and favor for all people, for in their belief nothing prevents God from saving such unfortunates with a hand reaching down from the clouds. That such exist everywhere without clothes or food, bedridden or shackled, is to them a conundrum to be explained for the sake of God's honor, not a call to the work of compassion. They are therefore overtaken by spiritual paralysis: they must turn away from 'the least of these' to preserve their fragile pious belief, or else must vilify and wage war against them as sinners. But to put an end to this theological hand-wringing and minister to them -- and then roll up sleeves and work for a world where no prison or famine or pandemic ever threatens? Such ideas gradually slip away from the mind of these men, replaced by the ever-encroaching aggrandizement of evangelism and conversion.

"This is slander against even the most cynical religious hypocrite," you may say, "after all, even the most puffed-up of the Evangelical types will feed the hungry, visit hospitals, and minister in prisons. They all read the same Matthew as you."

Very well, I don't at all fault them for any of these good works, nor am I meaning to lay blame on the good hearts and intentions of those who work tirelessly at their vocations while laboring under this religious framework. I am not interested in broad judgments against this or that sect, but what I will do is drive at a distinction in the character and motive of some of this work. For Jesus does the same in his prophecy of the coming of the Son of Man, at which many will recount their good works and yet receive a reply, "I did not know you."

What, then, is the fault of motive?

When one of the those I have in mind decides for himself that he will organize an effort to feed the hungry, he crushes within his heart the tender sympathy for their hunger, under the weight of his disordered notion of their salvation. Such a one will only provide food if it is accompanied by pamphlets. He will only visit the dying if he can work in an exhortation for their deathbed conversion. He founds prison ministries whose sole aim is the teaching of his interpretation of the Bible. Any work of charity not accompanied by an agenda called salvation is to them not merely empty, it is an abomination. And so, while they work diligently to ensure every meal is accompanied by a tract, they work just as diligently to undermine and disband every effort at public welfare without one.

Why are such religious people as I have described so eager to couple every act of charity with a concerted effort at conversion? The answer is no mere speculation; ask any one of them and they will tell you. To these, the far greater matter of concern in this life is that of right relation to God. All other needs, be it food or clothing or health, are subject to this. If you pressed one of this mind, they will tell you: it is better for any child to die hungry but claiming Jesus as her Lord, than it were for her to be fed and forget Him -- even if she spent her newfound life in peace and kindness toward all!

Now I will return to our parable and say: it is these who believe God is a harsh and exacting master, reaping what he did not sow! It is these who believe God waits with arm raised above the world, ready to smite any who do not pay him fealty and deference, even if they otherwise showered the earth with effusive grace and beauty. Their God is one who will burn even a good deed done with pure intentions, if it was not done in his name and to his so-called 'glory.'

Notice what the wicked servant is afraid of, and his response. What is it he has done? He has failed to love in abundance, failed to give increase to the spiritual gifts with which he was endowed, failed to work for the outpouring of the Spirit in his own heart and the heart of his community. And why not? Because he was afraid this abundance would be seized from him with malice by God. He does not trust the heart of the Lord, and so he turns his own heart to stone -- in order to preserve it, exactly as God gave it to him.

Such were the ones who said with spite against Jesus, he does not keep the Sabbath and he eats with sinners and tax collectors. Such were the party with whom Paul struggled, who could not conscience the lightening of the yoke and expansion of God's community to the Gentiles. And such are those everywhere who strain their whole lives against the unfolding of justice and unconditional love to all in the name of status quo.

For status quo is what the wicked servant took lengths to preserve. His god was one of stagnation, of maintenance and calcification. "What is the good," he says, "of increasing the breadth of my love and kindness -- of accepting the Muslim, of respecting and caring for my transgender child, of even acting with compassion for the addict sleeping in a tent -- if God may condemn me for the very desire for peace and human kindness I act upon?" He lives in fear that any step beyond the boundaries of grace and compassion which he received from his religion will meet the vengeance of his god, for his god is a harsh and exacting master who neither desires nor honors the work and good faith of his servants, but only comes calling to collect what he is owed to the penny. Of this god he lives in perpetual fear. This fear paralyzes him from doing the very work which the true God calls us to, and on which our own life and peace depends.

Therefore God responds to him in kind with his fear (here Luke, despite its troubles, holds this gem: the master says to him, "out of your own mouth I will judge you," directly signifying the mode of his response). We must hear his response sardonically, I believe. "Well then," says God, "you say I am harsh and unjust, and this is your excuse for burying your life in a hole! Then you would have been better off not believing in me at all and simply following the arc of the world as the faithful bend it toward love."

We should not think that Jesus would endorse lending with interest except sardonically. Jesus is not at all concerned with reversing the prohibition on interest found in the Law. He would rather his disciples expect no repayment whatsoever than stand to profit from lending2. What then must he mean by depicting the master as recommending it? Far from suggesting interest as a favorable alternative to labor, Jesus uses this comment to demonstrate contempt: better to commit usury than to do nothing. And now we must again put money aside and return to the spiritual meaning, before it becomes twisted.

We may instead frame the master's recommendation as this: if this is the whole profit of what you call faith (namely nothing) than better for you if you had not practiced any faith at all. So responds God to the man's slander: at least those who do not know me yet learn how to love one another with freedom and profit from it, even though their lives are not enlightened by an active and wise faith. Better to love freely but blindly, veering left and right, than to see the love of God interwoven in the whole of creation and yet make no step at all. But better still than either is the one who puts their heart to work in the lifelong pursuit of righteousness with their mind enlightened by the Spirit of Truth.

I do not intend to shy away from the conclusion of this parable, though I do approach it cautiously. The judgment of God, though true, is an astounding and harrowing ordeal. It is true in this important sense: that it reflects the true nature of spiritual reality. There is not a drop of capriciousness or cruelty in God's judgment. It may be, if you will allow me to suggest, that there is not even any direct act in it at all. For Jesus came declaring, "I judge no one," (Jn 8:15) yet also paradoxically, "The word I have spoken will judge," (Jn 12:48) and "my judgment is just" (Jn 5:30). The judgment of God is not like that of human courts; there is no deliberation of the correct sentence of punishment fit for each transgression. For human punishment is all a contingency: one effect (and one cause) among a series of worldly causes and effects. But God's justice is the foundation of the world.

When the Lord warns us to heed God's judgment -- which is the great aim of each of this series of parables in Matthew 25 -- he is not suggesting we attempt to garner the favor of God by fealty or religious partisanship to forestall God's act of punishment against us. Is our God a tyrant, with whom we should curry favor by flattery? No, God's justice is the very order of the universe, and it could not be otherwise. This is precisely why we cannot hope to escape it.

It is this justice, the inexorable spiritual process of the universe, by which the unworthy servant falls into desolation. He was given a heart with which to grow in love, and this, as with all people, was his sole vocation in life. That he failed to do so, even an iota, meant his life returned empty. In Jesus' commentary on the parable, he says this man is one of those who "does not have" -- not even his residual Talent is credited to him, for it was never his, only received3. What a person refuses to grow in themselves, God cannot impose upon them. The work cannot be skipped nor simulated. In this case, it was the man's true soul which he refused to work into being. Without it, what remains for him? The shadowy husk of his fabricated self, which falls to pieces. He is left in darkness until such a time as he is finally willing to take one step on the path of the Spirit and begin at last the work of love -- the work of becoming himself.

For this reason the Lord commands all who would follow him: be alert! Begin your work! Be prepared to give an account to your Creator: your account is your own soul, beatified in a lifelong vocation of loving kindness. God has placed in you the breath of life in order to produce such a harvest, and there is nothing for which God cares for more. Do not neglect the work of love such that this seed never takes root. Do not let it be choked by the mere accessory details of worldly affairs. Do not shy away from the hardship and persecution which accompanies it. Grow into yourself and embody the love of God which takes your name and face.

For God's breath of life in you will not return empty. God's work in you will not be thwarted. Be alert, be at work, while it is light and your siblings walk alongside you. If not, there at length comes a time when you are left so far behind that light and friendship may recede from you as well. Only we must take heart that there is not one who is left alone in this outer darkness, for God would leave the rest of the flock to recover them. Like the laborers hired in the eleventh hour, they will be caught up and restored in the due course of things to share in the same joy. But better for us if we heed the warning and resolve to begin our journey now.

Now, given how many words I have expended in attempting to explain the wisdom I see in this parable, a question inevitably arises: if this had been what the Lord had meant in giving it, why did he not simply 'say what he meant?' This question has echoed in the crowd since he first uttered a parable, and Jesus himself has answered it -- though with equal obscurity4.

The truth of God is not a thing to be known, but it is itself wisdom and life: it must be lived. All knowledge -- that is, all recognition of facts and systems -- is dead. At best it is dead as a seed is dead: fit to bring forth new life. But at worst it is a substitute for the living truth of God. Because even the dead knowledge of God's goodness is beautiful in comparison to the banalities of worldly concerns, it may sustain a well-meaning person for far too long in place of the real prize they ought to be seeking. When the seeker gives up the dead knowledge and pursues living righteousness, the knowledge is given back to them, renewed.

What, then? Can no word be given for all to hear, lest it become a stumbling block to the seeker? This is the role of the parable: to those who hear it without being worthy of it, it passes by in obscurity. The worthy hear it and are spurred on to life and righteousness, though they too grasp the meaning only lightly.

So the parables of Jesus serve two worthy aims:

First, they refuse to satisfy the mind of the seeker of wisdom; they give only enough purchase for them to continue climbing ever upward in the spiritual life and never enough to rest.

Second, their narrative provides a place for the hearer to inhabit and live in. It is through life that the Spirit grants insight, and so the wisdom of the parable emerges as the listener enters into it and lives within it. We are not merely given dictates of rights and wrongs. We must imagine and enliven, mull over motivations and even wonder with which character we may identify. Like our own lives, we construct and inhabit a story. Through this story, the Spirit enters in, and speaks in a voice which can never be heard in mere laws and concepts.

It would then be foolish for me to conclude this reflection by asserting that its contents represent a correct or definitive interpretation of the parable. An interpretation it is; and one which I believe is faithful to the Lord's overall teaching. However, a parable is not a puzzle to be solved. The frustrating part of writing (at length!) on the meaning of a parable is the inevitable truth: all of these ideas, all of these opinions, are dead as soon as they are on the page. The letter kills, the Spirit gives life. The parable alone is alive because the Spirit can live within it.

Therefore I am obliged, in the pattern of my greatest spiritual mentor, to close with an exhortation: take or leave my thoughts; follow Jesus. As I believe the parable says to us, so I will emphasize again: put theories aside and go about the work of love which God has prepared for you. Spend your life on the discovery of your very soul through the loving service of others. Having set aside all other things to gain your own soul, you will never cease in the gaining of it; more and more will you discover the gift of God which is your true life, the lives of all whom you love, and onward into the abundance of the whole human family. For the soul is the infinite thought of God, within whom all are one even as Jesus and the Father are one. This, and no other, is the vocation of the human person: not to know, not to achieve, not to acquire, but to love and become.